Affordable Beef Stroganoff

pic 093

I found myself pondering mushrooms and marriage the other day.

Back in the early days of our relationship, I would often quiz my husband about foods he liked to eat, foods he disliked, and foods that he wouldn’t eat if they were the last edible items on earth. One dish he said he loved was Beef Stroganoff. I thought,”Sweet! So do I!” However, mushrooms were in the “not with a ten foot pole” category. This led me to my first question: how can anyone hate mushrooms? Which was quickly followed by my second question: how exactly do you love beef stroganoff and hate mushrooms? Mushrooms are as integral to Beef Stroganoff as, well, beef! And finally, my third and most important question: could I still marry him after such a glaring flaw was pointed out to me? The conversation may, or may not, have gone something like this:

Me: What do you mean you don’t like mushrooms?
The husband: I just don’t.
Me:  All mushrooms?
The husband: Yes, all mushrooms.
Me: Poop.
The husband: Sorry.
Me: Beef Stroganoff is made with mushrooms.
The husband: No it’s not.
Me: Yes it is.  I’ll google it, you’ll see.
The husband (post goggle): Huh. The kind I always had didn’t have mushrooms.
Me: What kind was that?
The husband: You know, the one in the commercials. The box has a picture of a hand with a face on it.
Me: You mean Hamburger Helper?!?
The husband: Yeah! That’s it!


Years went by, during which time I tried countless variations of a mushroomless Beef Stroganoff, trying to find one that was so good, you forgot it was missing the best part.  Some turned out ok, some not, but none of them were the real deal, just homemade hamburger helper.  This mushroom-free era was a dark and difficult time in my life, but I like to think it made me stronger in the end.
Skip ahead to the present day. I prod the husband for dinner ideas, like I often do. He suggests Beef Stroganoff.  The conversation may, or may not, have gone something like this:

Me: So you know I have this food blog thingie, right?
The husband: Uh-huh.
Me: I’d like to post this recipe.
The husband: Ok..
Me:  Well, how would you feel if, um, I made it…..with mushrooms?
The husband: Sure.
Me: I’m sorry, what?
The husband: I said sure. I love everything you cook, so I’m willing to give the mushrooms a try.


pic 057

So what do mushrooms have to do with marriage? These flavorful fungi, besides tasting wonderful sautéed with a little butter, have helped me become more aware of a few things; that I did indeed marry the right man, that any good relationship stays healthy through mutual compromise, and that someone you thought you knew as well as you know yourself still has the capacity to surprise and delight you.

And for the record, he wasn’t thrilled with the mushrooms, but loved the overall flavor, and he ate every bite.

pic 011

Most Beef Stroganoff recipes call for beef tenderloin, or top sirloin, and you can go ahead and use that cut with this recipe, just skip the marinade step. For those of us (me) on a tighter budget, use a more affordable top round roast and a buttermilk marinade.  The buttermilk tenderizes the meat without adding any unwanted flavors that acids like vinegar or lemon juice bring to the party. The tang of the buttermilk blends in with the tang of the sour cream.  The other trick is to slice the meat at least 1/4 thick and fry it for no more than 30 seconds to 1 minute per side, otherwise it will dry out and get tough. 

Many of the ingredients in this recipe have been scaled or substituted to make this an affordable, budget friendly, family dish that doesn’t need to come out of a box.

pic 059

Some people sprinkle paprika as a garnish when serving.  I think it deserves a starring role, so I add it during the cooking.

pic 070

Mushrooms, glorious mushrooms. How I missed you.

pic 073

You must, *must* have plenty of sauce to drizzle over the egg noodles. It is required.

Affordable Beef Stroganoff
Adapted from Bon Appétit, September 1999 via Epicurious
Serves 6

2 lbs top round roast
2 cups buttermilk
2 tbsp canola or grapeseed oil
3 tbsp butter
1 med onion, diced
1 pound button mushrooms, sliced thick
1 tsp dried thyme
1 tsp paprika
2 tbsp flour
1 cup beef broth or stock
2 tbsp dry Sherry
1 cup sour cream
1 tsp Dijon mustard
2 tbsp chopped fresh parsley

Cut the meat into strips about 2 inches long, 1 inch wide and 1/4 inch thick. Place the meat in a large plastic freezer bag and add the buttermilk. Seal the bag and massage to make sure the meat is completely coated in buttermilk. Marinate at least overnight and up to 24 hours in the refrigerator.
Drain the meat and pat dry with paper towels. Season the meat with salt and pepper. Heat the oil in a skillet on med high heat. Fry the beef in batches until lightly browned, about 30 seconds per side. Remove from skillet and set aside. Reduce heat to medium and add butter to the same skillet.  Add onions and cook until translucent, about 5 minutes. Add mushrooms, thyme and paprika and cook until the mushrooms have softened and any liquid is evaporated, about 5 minutes. Sprinkle with flour, stir and cook for about a minute. Add the beef broth and the Sherry, reduce the heat to medium low and simmer until the mixture thickens slightly, about 5 more minutes. Return the meat and any juices to the pan and cook until just heated through, 2 – 3 minutes. Remove from heat and stir in the sour cream, Dijon and parsley. Season with salt and pepper to taste and serve over rice or egg noodles.

(Printable Recipe)

19 comments to Affordable Beef Stroganoff

  • That stroganoff looks great! It just wouldn’t be stroganoff without the mushrooms!

  • Michael

    Damn, I know I’ve been trying to get him and Steve to eat them for YEARS! Just like avocados. I finally got Steve hooked on guacamole but Jeff just never really caught on to it.

  • Karen

    Kevin: That is exactly the point I was trying to make to my husband 🙂

    Mike: I have girl power! Still a no go on the guac though…

  • I saw this post on FoodGawker (or one of the like), loved the picture, but diddn’t click. Glad to see it’s you! This looks absolutely delicious. I love a good stroganoff!

  • Ooo! I can’t wait to try this! The beef stroganoff I grew up on was made with cream of mushroom soup. This has got to be so much better! Thanks!

  • Dave

    I feel your pain of a no-mushroom spouse. Mine also doesn’t like sour cream so this will be saved for a night when she’s working late.

  • Karen

    Laura: Yep that was mine 🙂

    Tiffany: It’s such great comfort food, isn’t it? Really good for fall and winter.

    Dave: I’m glad someone shares my pain! I like just about everything that is cooked well. Except maybe liver. Liver is Ewww.

  • You’re absolutely right, stroganoff requires mushrooms. It’s just not the same without them. I was in your husband’s camp with the mushrooms are gross thing, but though I will never want to just chuck a handful into my mouth, there are things that just taste better with fungi.

    This recipe looks incredible. Growing up in the midwest, stroganoff meant Campbell’s Cream of Mushroom Substance of Dubious Origins, and I am looking forward to trying this out and erasing those flavor memories forever.

  • How can he not like mushrooms?!?! I adore them and this looks like a fantastic dinner!

  • Krista

    This sounds yummy! I wish I liked cooking.

  • Krista

    Yet I kind of want to try it anyway, but the recipe intimidates me! All this frying of parts of things, sounds hard!

  • This looks wonderful. Just maybe the best Beef Stroganoff recipe I’ve seen. Will most certainly give it a try over the next couple of weeks. Love the post. Thanks for the recipe.

    Lea Ann

  • its looks so cheesy and spicy from the pics hmm i just cant resist from the word mushroom everything tastes good when mushroom is added

  • Diane

    I was looking for inspiration since my dad is coming for dinner again (he comes over every Sunday since my Mom was hospitalized with dementia 4 years ago and I try not to repeat menu’s – crazy, huh?). I find and to be the best recipe resources in the universe and your recipe for stroganoff is simmering as I write this. The house smells amazing…my husband even wandered away from a football game on TV to find out what I was cooking!!! I felt compelled to return to your blog to thank you. Virtual hugs to you!

  • Rachel

    Made this recipe this morning. Very easy and tasty. I did the Buttermilk overnight+ for the Top Roast since my grandmother always comments on the “toughness”. She likes it but she still thinks Top Roast is only for “stews”. However, this is a good recipe and I would recommend making it anyway. I thought I would add a review for those who might be curious.

    Thank you for sharing the recipe.


  • Shan

    I googled “stroganoff no mushrooms” & came across this & really hoped to find a recipe without mushrooms. My spouse & I despise mushrooms (& he is highly allergic) so I’m always looking for a great recipe without. He actually hates sour cream, but for some reason he is ok with it in stroganoff. So if anyone put there has a really yummy version of mushroom-less stroganoff, there are thousands of us out here looking! Thank you! (ps- I did love tip on how to keep the meat from getting dry!)

  • Diane

    This is hilarious, my husband can’t stand mushrooms either but has gotten to the point that if he can’t see them he will eat them. Loved your post.

  • Hi can you substitute something for the sherry?i don’t drink and it would be an expensive ingredient. Thank you for your time.

    • Karen

      You can substitute white wine. I always keep a few of those mini bottles of white and red wine in my pantry for cooking. Also, you might be able to find a “shot” sized bottle of sherry at the liquor store. Good luck!