Green Tomato Muffins and the Birth of a Blog Post

green tomato muffins-9

Sometimes I get a great idea, or find an inspiring recipe and it’s tested, cooked, photographed and posted in just a few days.  Other times….

Not so much.

Follow along as I travel from this recipe’s conception, through the labor, and finally to the birth of a bouncing baby food blog post. May you LOL at the bumps along the way.

Sept. 5th: Saw a small basket of green tomatoes at the farmers market. Bought 3 tomatoes. Got home and wondered what the heck to do with them. Found a recipe for green tomato cake and thought about cupcakes.  Found this recipe for browned butter frosting.

Sept. 6th – 9th: Life, Labor Day, and laundry happened. Green tomatoes sit on counter next to bananas.  Not a smart move.

green tomato muffins

Sept. 10th: Shopped for ingredients after work. I hate shopping after work. Apparently, so does everyone else at the grocery store.

Sept. 11th: Piles of laundry to fold after work.  I am loudly reminded the family needs clean underwear.  Lost the natural light so made the executive decision to bake cupcakes tomorrow. I can do that, since I’m the executive chef.  It’s my kitchen and I can be executive chef if I want to be.

green tomato muffins-4

Sept. 12th: Discovered 2 green tomatoes have turned orangey, thanks to the over-ripe bananas I parked them next to for a week.  Farmers market closed, made emergency call to mother-in-law. She only had green cherry tomatoes. Shoot. Decided to make recipe anyway, leaving out the really, really orange bits.  Took lots of pictures.  Decided cupcakes are really chunky and look more like muffins, so I nix the browned butter frosting. Made a note to figure out what to do with extra-large bag of powdered sugar I don’t need anymore. First batch of muffins turn out ok, I think they could be better.  Raised temperature and cooking time on second batch. Much better.

green tomato muffins-2

Original recipe muffins: Batch 1

green tomato muffins-3

Original recipe muffins: batch 2

Sept. 13th-18th: Crazy week at work (re-occurring theme). At home there is Girl Scouts, fundraisers, and puberty (No, not me; my daughters). Thought about and ate muffins all week. Discovered I’m not 100% satisfied with recipe. Decided I need a really great apple muffin recipe where I can replace the apples with green tomatoes. Found a recipe on Smitten Kitchen, and the original recipe on the King Arthur Flour website.

Sept. 19: Bought more green tomatoes at the farmers market.  Put green tomatoes in the refrigerator this time. Also found some great sweet potatoes and discovered there was a bumper crop of tomatoes this fall. I buy a bunch. Will figure out what to do with them before they get fuzzy.  I know I will.

green tomato muffins-5

Sept. 20th: Green tomatoes are still in refrigerator. Was persuaded to go for a drive with the family instead of baking. I’m such a slacker.

Sept. 21st-23rd: Yet another crazy week at work. Too pooped to bake when I got home.  Still must cook and feed the family dinner or they whine and make lots of noise.

green tomato muffins-6

Sept .24: Shopped for ingredients after work. Have I mentioned that I hate shopping after work?

Sept. 25: Brother-in-Law’s birthday. No, I did NOT forget it was his birthday, nor did I forget we were going out to dinner on Friday for his birthday.  I simply forgot that it was Friday. Got home after dark. Green tomatoes are still in the refrigerator. Too afraid to check on them. Go to bed hoping they are still green.

green tomato muffins-7

Sept. 26: Cleaned and vacuumed the house. Am shocked, as always, at how much fur 3 cats and a dog lose in just a few days. Visited dentist with youngest daughter then spent the afternoon reading #blogherfood09 tweets. Wished I had been able to afford, and get the time off work, to go. No, I’m not jealous and I don’t hate everyone who went. Not anymore.

Sept. 27: Finally got off my lazy butt and baked the freakin’ muffins. Also made Nanaimo bars (future post) and Pork and Apple Stew (yet another future post). Must have found my motivational muse. Or had way too much coffee.

green tomato muffins-8

Sept. 28th-30th: Brought laptop to work and did some photo editing over lunch in the staff exercise room because it’s quiet and nobody uses it. Indulged in a quick giggle at the thought of edited muffin pictures in the exercise room. It’s the little things in life.

Oct 1st: Got home from work, which, not surprisingly, was crazy . Decided I really needed to post this since I’m working all weekend and next week is going to be crazy too (need to get a thesaurus and find me some crazy synonyms).

→Coming up:

Oct. 2nd: Go to work. Come home from work. Try to find time (or steal a chunk of sleep time) to post muffins to the usual suspect food porn sites. Remember to write up PDF of printable recipe and post it, not forget like I did with the last recipe.

Sometime Next Week: Sleep.

Green Tomato Muffins
Adapted from King Arthur Flour
Makes 12 Muffins

Green tomatoes add a surprising and subtle tart bite to these fall flavored muffuns.

1 cup whole wheat flour
1 cup all-purpose flour
1 tsp baking powder
1 tsp baking soda
¼ tsp kosher salt
2 tsp cinnamon
1 tsp nutmeg
½ cup unsalted butter, softened
½ cup sugar
¼ cup packed brown sugar, packed plus more for sprinkling
1 large egg, lightly beaten
1 cup buttermilk
1 ½ cups green tomatoes, seeded and chopped

Preheat oven to 450°F. Grease and flour muffin tin or line with paper cups. In a medium bowl, mix the flours, baking powder, baking soda, salt, cinnamon and nutmeg. In a large bowl, cream together the butter and sugars. Add the egg and mix well to combine. Gently stir in the buttermilk.* Stir in the flour mixture fold in the tomatoes.

Fill the muffin cups with the batter. Generously sprinkle the muffins with brown sugar. Bake for 10 minutes and then lower the oven temperature to 400°F. Bake for 15 to 20 minutes more. Muffins should be golden brown and a cake tester or toothpick inserted in the center of a muffin will come out clean. Cool for 10 minutes, then remove from tin and cool completely on a wire cooling rack.

*The original recipe warns about mixing gently or the buttermilk will curdle the mixture.  I don’t know if my gently stirred mixture “curdled”, per say, but I suspect the straight-from-the-fridge cold buttermilk just wouldn’t mix in very well with the butter. I just shrugged and went with it anyway, and the muffins were just fine.

(Printable Recipe)

Green Tomato on Foodista

21 comments to Green Tomato Muffins and the Birth of a Blog Post

  • I’m out of breath just reading this post! Man, you are busy, busy, busy. These muffins are so interesting. I’ve never heard of such a thing. I bet they are good.

    LOL about the conception, labor and birth reference. Very funny.

    I’m anxious for the Pork and apple stew recipe. I have a pork/apple stew recipe that has sauerkraut in it. Crock pot it all day and it’s delicious. I’m going to post it over the next month or so. We’re getting cooler weather now and will be digging out these types of recipes.

  • I’m intrigued, these sounds different and delicious!

  • very interesting muffins!
    i’ve been so anxious about what to with my under-ripe tomatoes in my garden. i want them to grow a little bit longer b4 i pick them, but then those annoying squirrels keep eyeing on them!!!!!
    now, i gotta pick them all and make this delicious muffins!
    thx a lot for sharing!

  • You indeed are busy! And I love the idea of muffins with green tomatoes. I too got a bunch from the farmer’s market yesterday – let’s see what comes out of them :))

  • Oh my gosh – those look great and what a hilarious post! you’re so creative and yes, I also hate shopping after work- yuck!

  • Congratulations on Top 9. This is my first visit, but I’ll definitely be back. I was very amused by this post and enjoyed poking around your blog.

  • It’s amazing how much work can go into a single blog post, isn’t it? 🙂 Looks like it was well worth it, though – those muffins look drool-worthy. Makes me wish I could get my hands on more green tomatoes (I made jam with mine).

  • I saw this post on tastespotting and just had to visit. I am glad I did. Not only does the recipe sound down right delicious, your post got me laughing. Glad you finally got to make these 🙂

  • Great idea. We always have lots of green tomatoes on hand. Love your creativity.

  • Margaret Lockhart

    I thought they were very good but I would mince the green tomatoes rather than just chop them. That way you avoid the look of the green tomatoe chunks that aren’t very appetising to most people (especially me and children in general). That way you get the value of the green tomatoes without the possibly offensive look of the larger chunks.

  • Hilarious post – and I can relate to the hectic household. Just made green tomato cake last night – a first for me. It’s a hit with the family.

  • I am cracking up at your daily recount! sounds like a hectic couple of weeks for you. These muffins are truly unique, I love the idea of making them into muffins

  • Fab! Lovely idea and a great fun to read post 🙂

  • Karen

    I know I’ve been MIA as far as comment replies, sorry guys. I’ve been reading and enjoying them all, but have not had time to reply. Glad you all got a kick out of my post diary 😀
    Margaret. I always appreciate feedback and ideas for improvement. I was going for a blueberry-type feel, with big bits of fruit in every bite. Mincing up the tomatoes is an intersting idea, though. I wonder how that would change the texture. Something for me to try if more green tomatoes come my way!

  • I don’t think I’ve ever had a green tomato. I may just have to.

  • Gloria

    I’ve eaten fried green tomatoes, but never thought about putting them in something sweet. Zucchini goes into sweet quick bread so why not tomatoes? Kudos for creativity!

  • What a post!I can also relate with the crazy schedule we have at home,this recipe here is really something else.I’d love to guide our readers to your site if you won’t mind.Just add your choice of foodista widget to this post and it’s all set, Thanks!

  • Karen

    Eric: Oh you must. Just so that you can say that you have been there, done that 😉

    Gloria: Thanks for the kudos! They really are quite good. All I had to do was lie to my children about what was in them, and they loved them 😉

    Alisa: I’m so glad I’m not alone! I really wish someone would invent artificial sleep or something. Maybe a freeze time machine, so I could keep going while the rest of the world is frozen. I added the widget, and roamed around the foodista website. Thanks so much for the prod to link up 🙂

  • both your blog and the muffins have come out really well


  • Jon

    These sound very interesting… I’m going to try them. I might use tomatillos instead of green tomatoes.

  • IndianaAnna

    I was searching the web for a muffin recipe to use up some of the green tomatoes we had left on our plants when fall hit and I found your recipe. The muffins turned out fabulous. I diced the tomatoes pretty small, subbed unsweetened applesauce for the butter to make them healthier, and since I did not have buttermilk I used plain yogurt. I will make again!